I've only just gotten back into papercrafting after quitting cold turkey 20 years ago, so here's some thoughts from the new customer market:
I do NOT think subscriber-only sets or early set access is a good idea. That seems likely to encourage piracy rather than subscription, and I understand pirates have been cutting into your bottom line a lot already. ("Yes, I'll spend 80 hours in time and $80 on paper and ink but not $11.50 on the actual design and artwork." Jerkfaces.)
Access to the back catalog is of much greater interest to me than getting each new release as it comes out, even with a discount on the new releases. (Although if you keep making more Deadfall sets, that may change. I want a boomtown, and standees, and trains, and mineworks, and a Sioux settlement, and a fort, and a farming homestead, and....)
As others have noted, access to the back catalog is valuable for exactly as long as it takes to download the whole thing - and even at the most, that's a few hours.
I think the wrong way to address this would be a "back catalog rental" sort of subscription, where you lose access to if your subscription lapses. That would cost money and time to implement, and probably would not accomplish much since pirates would get around those problems anyway. It would also make any month in which a subscriber did not print things out effectively wasted, which is not much of a selling point. If you get a set from a subscription, your license should be exactly the same as for buying it normally.
I like the idea a subscription including the purchase of a certain number of sets each month, which could be new releases, back catalog items, or a mixture of both. How many you get each month could depend on how many months you pay for at a time, for a simple example:
Monthly: 1 set at each renewal
Three-month subscription: 4 sets at each renewal
Six-month subscription: 10 sets at each renewal
Annual: Access to the full back catalog
One thing that I think would make a subscription system more appealing would be a regular release of small, inexpensive sets designed to expand the TLX range in general without necessarily acting as boosters/kitbashes for existing sets. For example: a "thatched roofing" set, a set of "snow-covered" transparencies that could slot onto TLX walls and roofs and over tiles, and specific prop-packs like food vendor carts, spider-web transparency inserts, new textures of crates, barrels, and chests, a single new texture for an existing vehicle kit, etc. Sets like these could act as regular (monthly?) releases, included with subscription but still available to non-subscribers for $2-4 each.
As for how much I, personally, would pay? I would pay $100-120 for a one-shot purchase of the existing catalog, entirely apart from any subscription deals for new sets.
|
